Whole Milk vs. Soy Protein Powder

Nutrition comparison of Whole Milk and Soy Protein Powder


Ever wonder how your favorite foods stack up against each other in terms of nutrition?

We compared the nutritional contents of whole milk versus soy protein powder (100g each) below using 2020 USDA and NIH data[1].

For a quick recap of significant nutrients and differences in whole milk and soy protein powder:

  • Both whole milk and soy protein powder are high in calcium.
  • Soy protein powder has more thiamin, niacin, Vitamin B6 and folate, however, whole milk contains more pantothenic acid and Vitamin B12.
  • Soy protein powder is an excellent source of dietary fiber, iron, potassium and protein.
  • Whole milk has signficantly less carbohydrates than soy protein powder.
  • Whole milk has signficantly more Vitamin D than soy protein powder.
Detailed nutritional comparison of whole milk and soy protein powder is analyzed below. You can also visualize the nutritional comparison for a custom portion or serving size and see how the nutrition compares.

USDA sources for nutritional information: Whole Milk (Milk, whole, 3.25% milkfat, with added vitamin D) and Soy Protein Powder (Protein powder, soy based, NFS) . Have a correction or suggestions? Shoot us an email.


Calories and Carbs

calories

Soy protein powder is high in calories and whole milk has 84% less calories than soy protein powder - whole milk has 61 calories per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 388 calories.

For macronutrient ratios, whole milk is much lighter in protein, much heavier in fat and similar to soy protein powder for carbs. Whole milk has a macronutrient ratio of 21:32:48 and for soy protein powder, 57:30:13 for protein, carbohydrates and fat from calories.

Macro Ratios from Calories:

Whole Milk Soy Protein Powder
Protein 21% 57%
Carbohydrates 32% 30%
Fat 48% 13%
Alcohol ~ ~

carbohydrates

Whole milk has signficantly less carbohydrates than soy protein powder - whole milk has 4.8g of total carbs per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 28.9g of carbohydrates.

The carbs in soy protein powder are made of 77% sugar and 23% dietary fiber, whereas the carbs in whole milk comprise of 100% sugar.

dietary fiber

Soy protein powder is an excellent source of dietary fiber and it has more dietary fiber than whole milk - soy protein powder has 6.7g of dietary fiber per 100 grams and whole milk does not contain significant amounts.

sugar

Soy protein powder is high in sugar and whole milk has 77% less sugar than soy protein powder - whole milk has 5.1g of sugar per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 22.2g of sugar.

Protein

protein

Soy protein powder is an excellent source of protein and it has 16 times more protein than whole milk - whole milk has 3.2g of protein per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 55.6g of protein.

Fat

saturated fat

Whole milk and soy protein powder contain similar amounts of saturated fat - whole milk has 1.9g of saturated fat per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 1.1g of saturated fat.

cholesterol

Soy protein powder has less cholesterol than whole milk - whole milk has 10mg of cholesterol per 100 grams and soy protein powder does not contain significant amounts.

Vitamins

Vitamin A

Whole milk has more Vitamin A than soy protein powder - whole milk has 46ug of Vitamin A per 100 grams and soy protein powder does not contain significant amounts.

Vitamin D

Whole milk has signficantly more Vitamin D than soy protein powder - whole milk has 51iu of Vitamin D per 100 grams and soy protein powder does not contain significant amounts.

Vitamin E

Whole milk and soy protein powder contain similar amounts of Vitamin E - whole milk has 0.07mg of Vitamin E per 100 grams and soy protein powder does not contain significant amounts.

Vitamin K

Whole milk and soy protein powder contain similar amounts of Vitamin K - whole milk has 0.3ug of Vitamin K per 100 grams and soy protein powder does not contain significant amounts.

The B Vitamins

Soy protein powder has more thiamin, niacin, Vitamin B6 and folate, however, whole milk contains more pantothenic acid and Vitamin B12. Both whole milk and soy protein powder contain significant amounts of riboflavin.

Whole Milk Soy Protein Powder
Thiamin 0.046 MG 0.288 MG
Riboflavin 0.169 MG 0.164 MG
Niacin 0.089 MG 2.357 MG
Pantothenic acid 0.373 MG ~
Vitamin B6 0.036 MG 0.164 MG
Folate 5 UG 289 UG
Vitamin B12 0.45 UG ~

Minerals

calcium

Both whole milk and soy protein powder are high in calcium. Soy protein powder has 58% more calcium than whole milk - whole milk has 113mg of calcium per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 178mg of calcium.

iron

Soy protein powder is an excellent source of iron and it has 399 times more iron than whole milk - whole milk has 0.03mg of iron per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 12mg of iron.

potassium

Soy protein powder is an excellent source of potassium and it has 607% more potassium than whole milk - whole milk has 132mg of potassium per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 933mg of potassium.

Omega-3 and Omega-6

omega 3s

For omega-3 fatty acids, soy protein powder has more alpha linoleic acid (ALA) than whole milk per 100 grams.

Whole Milk Soy Protein Powder
alpha linoleic acid 0.075 G 0.32 G
Total 0.075 G 0.32 G

omega 6s

Comparing omega-6 fatty acids, soy protein powder has more linoleic acid than whole milk per 100 grams.

Whole Milk Soy Protein Powder
linoleic acid 0.12 G 2.381 G
Total 0.12 G 2.381 G



Customize your serving size


The comparison below is by common portions, e.g. cups, packages. You can also see a more concrete comparison by weight at equal weight (by grams) comparison.

Note: The specific food items compared are: Whole Milk (Milk, whole, 3.25% milkfat, with added vitamin D) and Soy Protein Powder (Protein powder, soy based, NFS) .

Whole Milk g

()
Daily Values (%)

Soy Protein Powder g

()
KCAL %
calories
KCAL %
G %
carbohydrates
G %
G %
dietary fiber
G %
G sugar G
G %
total fat
G %
G %
saturated fat
G %
G monounsaturated fat G
G polyunsaturated fat G
G trans fat G
MG cholesterol MG
MG %
sodium
MG %
Vitamins and Minerals
UG %
Vitamin A
UG %
MG %
Vitamin C
MG %
IU %
Vitamin D
IU %
MG %
calcium
MG %
MG %
iron
MG %
MG %
magnesium
MG %
MG %
potassium
MG %
MG %
thiamin (Vit B1)
MG %
MG %
riboflavin (Vit B2)
MG %
MG %
niacin (Vit B3)
MG %
MG %
Vitamin B6
MG %
MG %
pantothenic acid (Vit B5)
MG %
UG %
folate (Vit B9)
UG %
UG %
Vitamin B12
UG %
MG %
Vitamin E
MG %
UG %
Vitamin K
UG %
G %
protein
G %
UG %
biotin (Vit B7)
UG %
MG %
choline
MG %
MG %
chlorine
MG %
UG %
chromium
UG %
MG %
copper
MG %
UG %
fluoride
UG %
UG %
iodine
UG %
MG %
manganese
MG %
UG %
molybdenum
UG %
MG %
phosphorus
MG %
UG %
selenium
UG %
MG %
zinc
MG %
G Water G
G Starch G
G Alcohol G


FAQ

Does whole milk or soy protein powder contain more calories in 100 grams?
Soy protein powder is high in calories and whole milk has 80% less calories than soy protein powder - whole milk has 61 calories in 100g and soy protein powder has 388 calories.

Is whole milk or soy protein powder better for protein?
Soy protein powder is a fantastic source of protein and it has 16 times more protein than whole milk - whole milk has 3.2g of protein per 100 grams and soy protein powder has 55.6g of protein.

Does whole milk or soy protein powder have more carbohydrates?
By weight, whole milk has signficantly fewer carbohydrates than soy protein powder - whole milk has 4.8g of carbs for 100g and soy protein powder has 28.9g of carbohydrates. the carbs in soy protein powder are made of 80% sugar and 20% dietary fiber, whereas the carbs in whole milk comprise of 100% sugar.

Does whole milk or soy protein powder contain more calcium?
Both whole milk and soy protein powder are high in calcium. Soy protein powder has 60% more calcium than whole milk - whole milk has 113mg of calcium in 100 grams and soy protein powder has 178mg of calcium.

Does whole milk or soy protein powder contain more iron?
Soy protein powder is an abundant source of iron and it has 399 times more iron than whole milk - whole milk has 0.03mg of iron in 100 grams and soy protein powder has 12mg of iron.

Does whole milk or soy protein powder contain more potassium?
Soy protein powder is a rich source of potassium and it has 610% more potassium than whole milk - whole milk has 132mg of potassium in 100 grams and soy protein powder has 933mg of potassium.